HomeLab Part 2 Server Hardware
On the previous post I started the discussion about HomeLabs. Now that we’ve laid out the reasons and things to look out for lets get into some hardware design ideas.
The first question to ask yourself is “Why am I building this HomeLab?”
If your main goal is to build an VCP Lab then we’ll have to get/build servers that are compatible with the VMware HCL. If it’s a Hyper-V lab then the Server Hardware has to support current versions of Windows Server.
Either way let go over some design principals that give you the best experiences possible.
1. When creating a HomeLab for server based functions, use server hardware.
2. When working with Linux or VMware avoid Realtek LAN cards like the plague.
3. In a server environment avoid the use of desktop mechanical drives.
Explanation of Design Principal 1:
When researching your hardware for your homelab you’ll find a lot of posts on other blogs and Reddit saying “I have (fill in asus or gigabyte desktop motherboard) and ESXi doesn’t detect the onboard raid” or “I have (fill in asus or gigabyte desktop motherboard) and it doesn’t detect (fill server grade raid card)”. My advise right off the bat is at the very minimum is to use server grade motherboard, and no a $500 gaming motherboard doesn’t count. To answer the statements above. Onboard Raid regardless if it is a desktop motherboard or server motherboard is crap when compared to even a $200 Hardware raid card like a LSI 9240. VMware and Linux support very few onboard solutions for that reason.
“But my gaming motherboard has this raid dedicated raid chip on the on the motherboard”. To be honest that doesn’t matter either to ESXi or Linux either. Onboard RAID usually relies on the CPU in some all functions so it’s not a true hardware based solution and with that the performance of the RAID is somehow connected to the CPU.
Also server grade RAID cards inject the RAID card’s bios into the motherboard’s bios. In most desktop motherboard’s there isn’t enough room for the RAID card’s bios so the motherboard ignores the RAID card.
Explanation of Design Principal 2:
I pointed out Linux and VMware especially for this because there is next to no support for Realtek LAN cards with Linux and no official support for VMware. But, in reality even in a windows environment Realtek should be avoided. Realtek network adapters are cheaply made and perform poorly in the best circumstances. If you use Design Principal 1 then you won’t have to to worry about this because there is absolutely 0 server motherboards that use Realtek network adapters. Use Intel Network Adapters, Intel network adapters perform the best, officially supported on every platform, and are affordable.
Explanation of Design Principal 3:
Desktop mechanical hard drives are only designed to support up to RAID 0 or RAID 1 (technically RAID 10 as well). There is no official support for RAID 5, RAID 6 or higher on desktop mechanical hard drives. For homelab’s Server Hard drives or NAS Drives. They are designed to handle RAID levels with parity information and be powered on 24/7. Server hard drives do have a bit of a price premium, but that is because they have a longer warranty and run time metrics.
Hard Drive Breakdown:
Western Digital 3.5″ 1TB SATA 7200 Newegg prices as of 5/21/2015
- WD Black Hard Drive $69.99
- WD Red NAS Hard Drive $64.99
- WD SE Server Hard Drive $89.99
- WD Raid Edition(RE) 4 Server Hard Drive $$99.99
I’ll save the in depth hard drive review for another time, but as you can see WD Red hard drives are actually cheaper then the top of the line desktop hard drive. WD Red hard drives support all RAID functions. The WD SE and WD RE4 hard drives have better performance for not that much more.
What Should I Buy:
This depends on how you want to build your lab Business servers or DIY. Obviously buying a brand new server or servers would cost more then some brand new cars.
Buying Used Servers off eBay:
Ebay is great place to find server equipment at a discount. Right now Dell PowerEdge R/T servers have the best value. Dell PowerEdge R610 go for around $200-$300 and you can added any extra RAM or Hard Drives you want. I’d avoid HP servers because on eBay, HP Server have a similar bloated value as Apple Products. The equivalent HP server is $1000 on ebay for the same functionality as a Dell PowerEdge R610 or R710.
Building Your Own Server:
When building your own server, Supermicro is your friend. All their components can be bought a separates, so you can build an entire Supermicro server or mix and match different components. Intel has a similar set up and in some cases are more feature full, but availability of their parts is not as good as Supermicro.
I hope this give you some good ideas for your homelab. I’ll be posting more soon about which exact parts to you and other design considerations. As always let me know what you think in the comments section.